“We’ve gotten ourselves into a position where we need Democrats with courage and/or Republicans with integrity, so we may be fucked.” – Me, 2018
“We’re fucked” – Me, 2024
One of the downsides of being a pessimist is that there’s no joy in being right.
I love people. Despite being an introvert and having a limit to my social energy, I really do like many individuals. People as a whole, that’s a different story. Throughout my life I’ve generally expected the worst from people. Still, every now and then, they surprise me with how bad they can get. When I say I generally expect the worst from people I mean that I expect many people to be dumb, ignorant, selfish, or short-sighted. Hell, there are times when I am dumb, selfish, or short-sighted. One of the things I’ve realized about myself is that I have a blind spot. What I don’t expect, and what truly catches me off-guard, is when people are just bad or evil. I see people, myself included, as basically good, even if we don’t always exhibit the best version of ourselves. Very rarely do I expect a person to truly act from bad motives. It’s bitten me more times than I like to admit.
I was a little surprised in 2016 when Trump won the presidency. Not as surprised as many, but still surprised. I grew up around Trump, so I always knew what a clown he was. I figured most people didn’t. I thought they fell for the Made-For-TV bullshit story of him being a successful businessman. I knew he would be a bad President, and sure enough he is consistently ranked by historians as one of the worst presidents we’ve ever had. Possibly THE worst president we’ve ever had. Honestly I figured the republican party would play along and then leave him out to dry at their earliest convenience. I thought that at the very least their self-interest would cause them to distance themselves from him eventually.
But then I have a blind spot when it comes to evil intentions.
When some republican politician would stand up to Trump and say “this is a line we will not cross” they would find themselves excommunicated from the party. Over the years, the ones who stood up lost their jobs. Now we’ve come to the point where I don’t think there’s anyone left who would dare stand up, and I’m not sure there’s any line left they wouldn’t cross. Looking back it seems like for the bulk of the party, this was the goal all along. Time after time, given a choice between the nation or power, they chose power. The few that briefly stood up were barely an inconvenience. They gave the illusion of integrity to a party that no longer felt the need to display any.
Which brings us to today. The 2024 election was yesterday. Trump won. Again, I’m not surprised that he won. I half expected it. Polls had been tight all along, which itself is an indictment of what America has become, and that’s kind of the problem isn’t it? The fact that the election was close at all felt like a big alarm going off, and something we would need to address, win or lose. Unfortunately now that we’ve lost, it may take decades to address it in a way that leaves us in a better place than we were last week.
When Trump won in 2016 only due to the Electoral College, most of the electorate didn’t really know what they were getting into. Sure the outright racists and fascists knew he was their guy but I think most people who voted for him bought into the TV image of a successful businessman. I figured they were just blind to who he really was. I didn’t expect him to get re-elected. The fact that 2020 was as close as it was was disappointing, but I thought that maybe enough people had finally seen enough of him to send him packing. After January 6th I thought his spell over all but the the most faithful would wane. I was wrong.
But then I have a blind spot when it comes to evil intentions.
You see, this time around people cannot claim ignorance. People know who Trump is, and they voted for him anyway.
One of the worst presidents in our history, and the only one to be impeached twice, and we voted for him. A convicted felon out on bail and with dozens of other charges against him, and we voted for him. A person found liable for sexual assault, and we voted for him. He took a good economy, cratered it, ran up record deficits, and this time has promised to effectively raise taxes on imported items by 20% or more, and we voted for him. His entire campaign was (again) almost entirely based on racism, and we voted for him. His own chief of staff and others who have worked for him have said that without a doubt he is a fascist and should never hold power again, and we voted for him. He has promised to jail his rivals and absolutely purge all Federal agencies of people who are not loyal to him personally, and we voted for him. We knew ahead of time that he would declare himself the winner and foment violence if he lost, but this time, he didn’t have to. We just handed it to him instead. The first time he was president we were stacking bodies in refrigeration trucks, and now we’re going to give him the job back. It seems like there’s no limit to what extremes Americans will go to to avoid electing a woman as President.
That’s the part that gets me. This wasn’t some Electoral College technicality achieved by pockets of zealots in a few states mixed with enough well-meaning people who were blind to the racism but thought they were getting an effective businessman. This was over 70 million people who saw the racism, misogyny, crimes, incompetence, and appeals to hatred and violence, and said “yep, that’s what we want.” They knew what they were voting for so yeah, while the result doesn’t necessarily surprise me, the failure of Americans to uphold American ideals feels very much like the end of something.
Even if Harris had won, I honestly don’t know how we’d get back to a place of having basic respect for one another and a sense of a shared society. Had she won it would have been a heavy lift but it would have at least been an opportunity to start. Yesterday the electorate effectively stated that they don’t even want a shared society any more. They don’t like the idea of America that their ancestors fought for. Maybe republicans are right, and some people just prefer to be ruled rather than represented. Either way, things are going to get worse for a while. Possibly a for a generation or more. Eventually they will get better again. Maybe not here, but somewhere. I hope I live long enough to see America become America again.
America might not be the largest civilization in human history. It probably won’t be the longest-lived in history. It will almost certainly go down as one of the dumbest.